How to Evaluate Vertical Lift Module Manufacturers: Why Spec Sheets Stop Being Comparable
The spec sheet that looked perfect—until we checked the fine print
In late 2023, I reviewed three vertical lift module proposals for our 180,000-square-foot distribution center. One quoted 4,200 storage positions at a 22-second average retrieval time. The next claimed 3,600 positions at 24 seconds. The third offered 3,000 positions at 20 seconds. Anyone would look at those numbers and put the first vendor at the top of the list.
That's the intuition. And it's exactly the trap.
When I pulled the actual size and dimension data from each manufacturer, the story changed. The "4,200 positions" vendor counted each pick compartment as a full unit—regardless of shelf height or load class. The "3,600 positions" vendor counted pallet positions. The third counted dynamic pick faces. I'm not suggesting any of them lied. I'm saying the numbers had no common denominator. Comparing them was like comparing square feet to running meters and calling it a shopping decision.
Why vertical lift module specifications are harder to compare than they look
Here's the part most buyers don't think about until after the purchase order goes out: there is no enforced standard for how VLM manufacturers report capacity, retrieval time, or available height. I've now reviewed more than 60 automation proposals in four years, and the gaps tend to follow the same patterns.
1. "Storage positions" is not a controlled term
What most people don't realize is that one manufacturer's "position" may be a tote face, another's may be a full shelf level, and a third may be a theoretical slot defined by the narrowest possible tray configuration. When I compared three "500-pallet" systems in 2023, the usable rack storage area differed by 40%. Same phrase on the cover, three different realities inside.
What I need from every vendor is the calculation themselves—not just the total. Show me the assumed tray width, shelf height, load weight, and number of trays per level. If they can't or won't, the number is decoration.
2. Retrieval time is often measured on the nearest tray
Most spec sheets quote "minimum retrieval time"—which is the fastest possible path, usually from the closest tray to the access opening. That's not your retrieval time. Your retrieval time depends on how inventory is distributed across trays, and that depends on your SKU velocity profile.
A vendor quoting "18 seconds" based on uniform distribution will look very different in a facility running a heavy 80/20 SKU mix. The average path will be longer. I've seen proposals downplay this by calling the figure "typical" without defining the test conditions.
My rule now: ask for the test protocol. Distance, load weight, tray configuration, and velocity assumption. If the vendor can't define those, the number belongs in the marketing folder, not the comparison spreadsheet.
3. Bulk racking and VLM data get blended in ways that distort both
Bulk racking is a separate problem with its own terminology. Pallet racking capacity should be calculated per ANSI MH16.1, and the distinction between "system capacity" and "per-bay capacity" is frequently blurred in procurement documents. I reviewed a 2024 proposal that claimed 12,000 pounds of system capacity—only to find, after asking for the beam-load calculations, that the number included unused beam levels and an optimistic load factor. Real usable capacity was closer to 9,600 pounds.
That's why I now require ANSI MH16.1 calculations as a separate appendix. If the VLM and the pallet racking are quoted together, I want the numbers separated by product type and standard. Mixing them inflates one and disguises the other.
4. Available height and overhead clearance are not interchangeable
I once signed off on a system where the quoted "total height" fit our building on paper. Six months later, the installers discovered the manufacturer had included a safety clearance that didn't match our actual ceiling obstructions. We had to rework the top guide rails—$18,000 in rework and certification, plus a five-week delay.
Now I require two separate dimensions in every quote: the unit's physical height and the required operational clearance. It's a five-minute email. It has saved us six figures since 2022.
What those errors actually cost
The most expensive part of a bad comparison isn't the purchase price. It's the decisions you make afterward based on numbers you thought were comparable.
When a supplier wins a project using undefined or optimistic metrics, the shortfall shows up in operations. Throughput expectations don't materialize. Redesign work eats into launch schedules. And the internal bandwidth spent fixing those problems is never on the original budget line.
There's also a time-cost dimension that procurement teams routinely undervalue. If your lease starts on a fixed date, or you're trying to hit a peak-season window, a delayed install isn't just annoying—it's expensive. You're paying rent or labor for a system that isn't producing.
The quoted price is what you pay the vendor. The true cost is what you pay while waiting for the vendor's estimate to become a reality.
That's why I started treating schedule certainty as a standalone evaluation criterion, not a footnote. A vendor that commits to a guaranteed installation window with contractual penalties may price 5-10% higher upfront. Once I factor in the cost of a four-week delay—extended labor, missed capacity, emergency redesign fees—that premium often disappears, or inverts.
I can only speak to our facility size and throughput profile. If you're running a micro-fulfillment setup or a highly seasonal operation, the math will look different. But the principle held for us: paying for certainty is cheaper than paying for optimism.
A practical evaluation framework for vertical lift module manufacturers
This isn't a complete procurement manual. It's the minimum I require before a proposal enters the comparison stage. Without these five items, I reject the submission.
- Define your own units first. Before any vendor sends a proposal, write down what "position," "tray," "retrieval time," and "available height" mean for your operation. Put those definitions in the RFQ. Vendors who respond using your terms—not their marketing terms—move to the next round.
- Ask for the sample-batch math. Don't accept total capacity. Ask for one sample SKU batch with the exact tray count, shelf height, weight class, and cube calculation. Good vendors already have this granular data. Weak vendors produce a single number.
- Separate bulk racking from VLM specifications. Require ANSI MH16.1 calculations for pallet racking and FEM 9.851 data for vertical lift module performance. Keep the categories separated in the proposal. If a vendor merges them, ask why.
- Check the manufacturer's public documentation. Detailed spec sheets published on a manufacturer's official website—Hänel storage systems publishes theirs, which is how I first started comparing—are a sign the vendor is used to external scrutiny. If a manufacturer's own website doesn't have detailed specifications, you'll spend the procurement process asking questions that should already have answers.
- Price the delay, not just the equipment. Calculate what four extra weeks of rent, labor, or missed peak-season sales would cost your operation. Then look at the quotes again. A vendor offering a guaranteed install date with penalties is not expensive; it's priced for the risk they're carrying.
That's it. None of this is revolutionary. But it changes the conversation from "which number is bigger" to "which number can we trust"—and that's a much better conversation to have before the purchase order, not after the installation.
Leave a note
Project comments are reviewed by the Hänel application desk. Do not submit credentials or confidential drawings in this box.